Trusted by 12,000+ American singles since 2020

Find the one who truly gets you.

Personalized matchmaking for thoughtful singles across the USA. We pair human intuition with careful questions, so every introduction feels like fate — not a swipe.

5+ Years of Matching
3,400+ Happy Couples
92% Match Satisfaction
Happy couple embracing outdoors
M
New match nearby 2 miles away · Online
♥
94% compatibility Based on 47 traits
Couple sharing a quiet moment together
5 Years Trusted Matchmaking
About Better Dating Choices

A modern matchmaking service with an old-fashioned heart.

Founded in 2020 in Valley City, Ohio, Better Dating Choices was born from a simple belief: real love deserves more than an algorithm and a thumbnail. Our team blends thoughtful human matchmaking with careful profile curation, helping singles across all fifty states find partners who genuinely fit their lives.

Every member is met personally, every story is heard, and every introduction is intentional. That is the difference five years of focused work makes.

Vision

A world where no one settles for less than a soul-aligned partner.

Mission

To guide sincere singles toward lasting relationships through care, not chance.

Values

Honesty, kindness, patience, and respect for every story we are trusted with.

Principles

Quality over quantity, real conversations over quick matches, people over profit.

Our Journey

Five years,
thousands of love stories.

0
Years of Service
0
Active Members
0
Successful Couples
0
States Covered
Why Choose Us

Matchmaking that feels personal.

We bring warmth back to dating with a service designed around your story, your time, and your hopes for the future.

Curated Matches

Each introduction is hand-selected by a real human matchmaker who reads your story, not just your stats.

Verified Profiles

Every member goes through identity verification and a private intake call before joining our circle.

Nationwide Network

From small Ohio towns to the coasts of California, our member circle spans all fifty states.

Real Coaching

Get one-on-one dating guidance from coaches who care about your growth, not just your matches.

Private & Secure

Your information is encrypted, never sold, and only shared with matches you approve.

Proven Results

Over 3,400 couples formed and a 92 percent satisfaction rate from members past and present.

How It Works

Four simple steps to something real.

01

Share Your Story

Tell us about your life, values, and what you are truly looking for in a partner.

02

Meet Your Matchmaker

A personal matchmaker reviews your profile and reaches out for a private consultation call.

03

Receive Curated Intros

We hand-pick compatible members and arrange thoughtful introductions at your pace.

04

Build Something Real

Get ongoing coaching and feedback as you turn first dates into a lasting connection.

What We Offer

Services crafted for
every kind of heart.

From serious matchmaking to casual companionship, our services meet you exactly where you are in life.

Most Popular Couple laughing together on a date

Online Dating Matchmaking

Smart, human-guided matchmaking that pairs you with compatible singles based on values, lifestyle, and long-term goals.

Learn more
Premium Elegant couple at a candlelit dinner

Premium Dating Memberships

Priority matching, dedicated coach, and access to our exclusive circle of vetted singles across the United States.

Learn more
Guidance Two people in a thoughtful coaching conversation

Dating Advice & Tips

One-on-one coaching sessions to help you feel confident, authentic, and ready for real connection on every date.

Learn more
Warm Friends enjoying a relaxed afternoon together

Friendship & Companionship

Not looking for romance yet? Find genuine companions who share your interests, hobbies, and weekend plans.

Learn more
Membership Packages

Choose the plan that
fits your story.

Transparent pricing, no hidden fees, and every plan can be cancelled anytime.

Starter

For singles ready to dip their toes into meaningful dating.

$49 / month
  • Up to 3 curated matches per month
  • Verified member profiles
  • Standard customer support
  • Access to community events
  • Basic compatibility insights
Get Started

Elite

A white-glove experience for those who want the very best.

$299 / month
  • Unlimited curated matches
  • Dedicated senior matchmaker
  • Weekly coaching calls
  • Date planning & concierge service
  • Background checks on matches
  • Private VIP events access
Get Started
Couple in love
Join the Circle

Begin your
membership application.

Fill in a few details and a matchmaker will reach out within 48 hours to schedule your private consultation.

Membership Application

Tell us a little about you. All fields are kept strictly private.

Love Stories

Real words from real couples.

Honest stories from members who said yes to a different kind of dating experience.

★★★★★

"I had almost given up on dating apps. Better Dating Choices introduced me to someone who actually understood me. We are getting married next spring."

SM
Sarah Mitchell New York, NY
★★★★★

"The matchmaker really listened. After two intros I met Emily, and everything just clicked. The coaching calls made a huge difference for me."

JA
James Anderson Austin, TX
★★★★★

"As a busy professional I had no time for games. Better Dating Choices respected my time and found me someone on the same page about life."

ER
Emily Rodriguez Seattle, WA
★★★★★

"The verification process made me feel safe. Every match was a real person with serious intentions. Cannot recommend this team enough."

MT
Michael Thompson Chicago, IL
★★★★★

"I joined for friendship first and ended up meeting the love of my life. The pace is gentle and the people are genuine. Worth every penny."

JC
Jessica Carter Miami, FL
★★★★★

"After my divorce I was nervous to date again. My matchmaker was patient and kind. Six months later I am in the healthiest relationship of my life."

DP
David Patel San Francisco, CA
Questions Answered

Frequently asked questions.

Every member completes a detailed intake questionnaire and a private consultation call. Your dedicated matchmaker then reviews values, lifestyle, and relationship goals to hand-select compatible introductions — no algorithms doing the deciding.
Absolutely. We use bank-grade encryption, never sell your data, and only share your profile with matches you have explicitly approved. Your privacy is the foundation of our service.
Dating apps reward swiping and surface-level photos. We reward sincerity and intention. You will never be matched with someone based on a thumbnail — every introduction is chosen by a human who has read your story.
Most members receive their first introduction within seven to ten days of joining. The right match may take longer — we prioritize quality of connection over speed of delivery.
Yes. We offer a 14-day cooling-off period on all memberships with a full refund. After that, partial refunds are available based on the remaining time on your plan — see our Terms & Conditions for full details.
Every member goes through identity verification. Elite tier members receive full background checks on all matches, and any member can request a background check at an additional fee.
Yes, you can pause your membership for up to 90 days per year without losing your remaining time. Simply contact your matchmaker or our support team to arrange a pause.
We serve all fifty states with active member circles in major metros and rural communities alike. Our matchmakers work remotely and in person, so location is never a barrier to finding your person.

Your soulmate is closer than you think.

Take the first step today. A free, no-pressure consultation with a real matchmaker is just one click away.

Book Free Consultation
Get In Touch

Let's start a conversation.

Questions about memberships, matchmaking, or anything else? We would love to hear from you.

Call Us (330) 483-6023
Visit Us 1834 Abbeyville Rd,
Valley City, Ohio 44280, USA
Office Hours Mon – Sat: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM EST
Sunday: By appointment

Send us a message

We typically reply within 24 hours.